Research Review Assignment

Writing a literature review

Critical Evaluation

Your literature review should include a critical examination of the material that you have read.

There are many factors that you need to keep in mind when reading a piece of work. Factors such as the sample size, research design, measures used, biases, extraneous or confounding variables will need to be considered.

Design a checklist that you can use as a template when evaluating written material. This will allow you to be consistent in your evaluations. Ask for input from your supervisor when designing it; you are required to reduce your own biases and a checklist is an effective way to do this.

Begin with the questions in the section on critical reading. Ask yourself how the research is relevant to your study, and how it is different from your study.

Download a literature review worksheet (176KB)

Audience

Keep in mind your audience when you write the review and do not presume that they know what you do.

When researching your topic, you will have immersed yourself (or been overwhelmed!) in the subject, so do not assume that even your supervisor or the committee is privy to the things you now know.

On the other hand, there is no need to state the obvious. If you are not sure whether to include definitions, elaboration, or expansion on certain topics, ask your supervisor for feedback.

Scope

When you begin your reading, do not over-read; restrict the size of your reading to allow you to actually get on with the review. Read articles twice: the first time to understand themes and concepts, the second time with a critical eye.

You will be required to know a great deal about the topic (especially for a PhD), but you may not have to write everything you know about it. You may be able to limit the scope of the review to include the current state of the theory as it stands to date.

How far back is far enough? That depends on the level of your research, but a rough guide for Masters Theses is about 10 years, unless a more extensive investigation is required, this last point being of particular relevance to doctoral students (Mauch & Birch, 1998).

Length

The length of your review will vary as well as the format. Discuss with your supervisor what would be a suitable length rather than being verbose and less concise than you should be.

The review should demonstrate your ability to synthesize a body of literature. It may be better to have a briefer, more focused review than a lengthy one. Whatever you decide, discuss this issue with your supervisor.

References and further reading

Mauch, J. E., & Park, N. (2003). Guide to the successful thesis and dissertation: A handbook for students and faculty (5th ed.). New York, NY: Marcel Dekker. [Massey Library link]

Page authorised by Director, CTL
Last updated on 5 February, 2018

 

Advance Research Methodology Literature Review

Hailey College Of Commerce Page

3

P

urpose of a Literature Review

The purpose of a literature review is to convey to the reader what knowledge andideas have been established on a topic and what are the strengths and weaknesses.The literature review allows the reader to be brought up to date regarding thestate of research in the field and familiarizes the reader with any contrastingperspectives and viewpoints on the topic. There are good reasons for beginning aliterature review before starting a research paper. These reasons include:

y

To see what has and has not been investigated.

y

To develop general explanation for observed variations in a behavior orphenomenon.

y

To identify potential relationships between concepts and to identifyresearchable hypotheses.

y

To learn how others have defined and measured key concepts.

y

To identify data sources that other researches have used.

y

To develop alternative research projects.

y

To discover how a research project is related to the work of others.

Im

portance of Literature Review

Research is made in order to inform people with new knowledge or discovery.

H

owever, it is not to be expected that everybody would willingly believe what youare tackling in your whole research paper. Thus, what you can do to make yourresearch more credible will be to support them with other works which havespoken about the same topic that you have for your research. This is whereliterature review comes in.You can even have literature sources in works such as stories, comments, project,speech, article, novel, poem, essay, program, theory, and others. This is whyliterature review involves scanning the pages of any published literature like books,newspaper, magazine, website, webpage, collection, paper, pamphlet, and the likewhere you may be able to find any reference to the same topic that you areresearching on. This time,

´

literature·µ does not exclusively refer to the poeticrendition of words, like that of Shakespeare alone.

0 thoughts on “Research Review Assignment”

    -->

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *