Annual Report Analysis Research Paper

Financial Statement Analysis is a method of reviewing and analyzing a company’s accounting reports (financial statements) in order to gauge its past, present or projected future performance. This process of reviewing the financial statements allows for better economic decision making.

Globally, publicly listed companies are required by law to file their financial statements with the relevant authorities. For example, publicly listed firms in America are required to submit their financial statements to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Firms are also obligated to provide their financial statements in the annual report that they share with their stakeholders. As financial statements are prepared in order to meet requirements, the second step in the process is to analyze them effectively so that future profitability and cash flows can be forecasted.

Therefore, the main purpose of financial statement analysis is to utilize information about the past performance of the company in order to predict how it will fare in the future. Another important purpose of the analysis of financial statements is to identify potential problem areas and troubleshoot those.

© Shutterstock.com | samui

Here, we will look at 1) the users of financial statement analysis, 2) the methods of financial statement analysis, 3) key accounting reports (the balance sheet, income statement, and statement of cash flows) and how they are analyzed, 4) other financial statement information, and 5) problems with financial statement analysis.

USERS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS

There are different users of financial statement analysis. These can be classified into internal and external users. Internal users refer to the management of the company who analyzes financial statements in order to make decisions related to the operations of the company. On the other hand, external users do not necessarily belong to the company but still hold some sort of financial interest. These include owners, investors, creditors, government, employees, customers, and the general public. These users are elaborated on below:

1. Management

The managers of the company use their financial statement analysis to make intelligent decisions about their performance. For instance, they may gauge cost per distribution channel, or how much cash they have left, from their accounting reports and make decisions from these analysis results.

2. Owners

Small business owners need financial information from their operations to determine whether the business is profitable. It helps in making decisions like whether to continue operating the business, whether to improve business strategies or whether to give up on the business altogether.

3. Investors

People who have purchased stock or shares in a company need financial information to analyze the way the company is performing. They use financial statement analysis to determine what to do with their investments in the company. So depending on how the company is doing, they will either hold onto their stock, sell it or buy more.

4. Creditors

Creditors are interested in knowing if a company will be able to honor its payments as they become due. They use cash flow analysis of the company’s accounting records to measure the company’s liquidity, or its ability to make short-term payments.

5. Government

Governing and regulating bodies of the state look at financial statement analysis to determine how the economy is performing in general so they can plan their financial and industrial policies. Tax authorities also analyze a company’s statements to calculate the tax burden that the company has to pay.

6. Employees

Employees need to know if their employment is secure and if there is a possibility of a pay raise. They want to be abreast of their company’s profitability and stability. Employees may also be interested in knowing the company’s financial position to see whether there may be plans for expansion and hence, career prospects for them.

7. Customers

Customers need to know about the ability of the company to service its clients into the future. The need to know about the company’s stability of operations is heightened if the customer (i.e. a distributor or procurer of specialized products) is dependent wholly on the company for its supplies.

8. General Public

Anyone in the general public, like students, analysts and researchers, may be interested in using a company’s financial statement analysis. They may wish to evaluate the effects of the firm on the environment, or the economy or even the local community. For instance, if the company is running corporate social responsibility programs for improving the community, the public may want to be aware of the future operations of the company.

METHODS OF FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS

There are two main methods of analyzing financial statements: horizontal or trend analysis, and vertical analysis. These are explained below along with the advantages and disadvantages of each method.

Horizontal Analysis

Horizontal analysis is the comparison of financial information of a company with historical financial information of the same company over a number of reporting periods. It could also be based on the ratios derived from the financial information over the same time span. The main purpose is to see if the numbers are high or low in comparison to past records, which may be used to investigate any causes for concern. For example, certain expenditures that are high currently, but were well under budget in previous years may cause the management to investigate the cause for the rise in costs; it may be due to switching suppliers or using better quality raw material.

This method of analysis is simply grouping together all information, sorting them by time period: weeks, months or years. The numbers in each period can also be shown as a percentage of the numbers expressed in the baseline (earliest/starting) year. The amount given to the baseline year is usually 100%. This analysis is also called dynamic analysis or trend analysis.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Horizontal Analysis

When the analysis is conducted for all financial statements at the same time, the complete impact of operational activities can be seen on the company’s financial condition during the period under review. This is a clear advantage of using horizontal analysis as the company can review its performance in comparison to the previous periods and gauge how it’s doing based on past results.

A disadvantage of horizontal analysis is that the aggregated information expressed in the financial statements may have changed over time and therefore will cause variances to creep up when account balances are compared across periods.

Horizontal analysis can also be used to misrepresent results. It can be manipulated to show comparisons across periods which would make the results appear stellar for the company. For instance, if the profits for this month are only compared with those of last month, they may appear outstanding but that may not be the case if compared with the same month the previous year. Using consistent comparison periods can address this problem.

Vertical Analysis

Vertical analysis is conducted on financial statements for a single time period only. Each item in the statement is shown as a base figure of another item in the statement, for a given time period, usually for year. Typically, this analysis means that every item on an income and loss statement is expressed as a percentage of gross sales, while every item on a balance sheet is expressed as a percentage of total assets held by the firm.

Vertical analysis is also called static analysis because it is carried out for a single time period.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Vertical Analysis

Vertical analysis only requires financial statements for a single reporting period. It is useful for inter-firm or inter-departmental comparisons of performance as one can see relative proportions of account balances, no matter the size of the business or department.

Because basic vertical analysis is constricted by using a single time period, it has the disadvantage of losing out on comparison across different time periods to gauge performance. This can be addressed by using it in conjunction with timeline analysis, which shows what changes have occurred in the financial accounts over time, such as a comparative analysis over a three-year period. For instance, if the cost of sales comes out to be only 30 percent of sales each year in the past, but this year the percentage comes out to be 45 percent, it would be a cause for concern.

KEY FINANCIAL STATEMENTS & HOW THEY ARE ANALYZED

The main types of financial statements are the balance sheet, the income statement and the statement of cash flows. These accounting reports are analyzed in order to aid economic decision-making of a firm and also to predict profitability and cash flows.

I. The Balance Sheet

© Wikimedia Commons

The balance sheet shows the current financial position of the firm, at a given single point in time. It is also called the statement of financial position. The structure of the balance sheet is laid out such that on one side assets of the firm are listed, while on the other side liabilities and shareholders’ equity is shown. The two sides of the balance sheet must balance as follows:

Assets = Liabilities + Shareholders’ Equity

The main items on the balance sheet are explained below:

Current Assets

Current assets held by the firm refer to cash and cash equivalents. These cash equivalents are assets that can be easily converted into cash within one year. Current assets include marketable securities, inventory and accounts receivable.

Long-term Assets

Long-term assets are also called non-current assets and include fixed assets like plant, equipment and machinery, and property, etc.

A firm records depreciation of its fixed, long-term assets every year. It is not an actual expense of cash paid, but is only a reduction in the book value of the asset. The book value is calculated by subtracting the accumulated depreciation of prior years from the price of the assets.

Total Assets = Current Assets + Book Value of Long-Term Assets

Current Liabilities

Current liabilities of the firm are obligations that are due in less than one year. These include accounts payable, deferred expenses and also notes payable.

Long-term Liabilities

Long-term liabilities of the firm are financial payments or obligations due after one year. These include loans that the firm has to repay in more than a year, and also capital leases which the firm has to pay for in exchange for using a fixed asset.

Shareholders’ Equity

Shareholders’ equity is also known as the book value of equity or net worth of the firm. It is the difference between total assets owned by a firm and total liabilities outstanding. It is different from the market value of equity (stock market capitalization) which is calculated as follows: number of shares outstanding multiplied by the current share price.

Balance Sheet Analysis

The balance sheet is analyzed to obtain some key ratios that help explain the health of the firm at a given point in time. These metrics are as follows:

Debt-Equity Ratio = Total Debt / Total Equity

The debt-equity ratio is also called a leverage ratio. It is calculated to assess the leverage, or gearing, of a firm to show how much it relies on debt to finance its activities. This ratio has pertinent implications for the financial health of the firm and the risk and return of its shares.

Market-to-Book Ratio = Market Value of Equity / Book Value of Equity

The market-to-book ratio is used to reflect any changes in a firm’s characteristics. The variations in this ratio also show any value added by the management and its growth prospects.

Enterprise Value = Market Value of Equity + Debt – Cash

The enterprise value of a firm shows the underlying value of the business. It reflects the true value of the firm’s assets, not including any cash or cash equivalents, while unencumbered by the debt the firm carries.

II. The Income Statement

© Wikimedia Commons | Microsoft

The purpose of an income statement is to report the revenues and expenditures of a firm over a specific period of time. It was previously also called a profit and loss account. The general structure of the income statement with major components is as follows:

Sales revenue

– Cost of goods sold (COGS)

= Gross profit

– Selling, general and administrative costs (SG&A)

– Research and development (R&D)

= Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA)

– Depreciation and amortization

= Earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT)

– Interest expense

= Earnings before taxes (EBT)

– Taxes

= Net income

The net income on the income statement, if positive, shows that the company has made a profit. If the net income is negative, it means the company incurred a loss.

Earnings per share can be derived from knowing the total number of shares outstanding of the company:

Earnings per Share = Net Income / Shares Outstanding

Income statement Analysis

Some useful metrics based on the information provided in the income statement and the balance sheet are as follows:

Profitability Ratios:

1. Net profit margin: This ratio calculates the amount of profit that the company has earned after taxes and all expenses have been deducted from net sales.

Net profit Margin =Net Income / Net Sales

2. Return on Equity: This ratio is used to calculate company profit as a percentage of total equity.

Return on Equity = Net Income / Book Value of Equity

Valuation Ratios:

Price to earnings ratios (P/E ratio)

The P/E ratio is used to evaluate whether the value of a stock is proportional to the level of earnings it can generate for its stockholders. It assesses whether the stock is overvalued or undervalued.

(P/E) Ratio = Market Capitalization / Net Income = Share Price / Earnings per Share

III. The Statement of Cash Flows

The statement of cash flows shows explicitly the sources of the firm’s cash and where the cash is utilized. It is essentially a statement whereby the net income is adjusted for non-cash expenses and any changes to the net working capital. It also reflects changes in cash coming from, or being used by, investing and financing activities of the firm. The structure and main components of the cash flow statement are as follows:

Cash from operating activities = Net income + Depreciation ± Changes in net working capital

Cash from financing activities = New debt + New shares – Dividends – Shares repurchased

Cash from investment activities = Capital expenditure – Proceeds from sales of long-term assets

All three of the above determine the bottom line: changes in cash flows.

Cash Flows Statement Analysis

In order to measure how much cash is available to the company for investments without outside financing or money diverting from operations, it is useful to conduct a simple cash flow statement analysis. The free cash flow, as the name suggests, allows a company to be able to pay dividends, repay its debts, buy back its stock and also make new investments to facilitate future growth. The excess cash produced by the company, free cash flow, is calculated as follows:

Net Income

+ Amortization/Depreciation

– Changes in Working Capital

– Capital Expenditures

= Free Cash Flow

Some analysts also study the cash flow from operating activities to see if the company is earning “quality” income. In order for the company to be doing extremely well, the cash from operating activities must be consistently greater than the net income earned by the company.

OTHER FINANCIAL STATEMENT INFORMATION

Apart from the key financial statements, complete financial reporting statements also include the following:

Business and Operating Review

The business and operating review is also called “management discussion and analysis”. It serves as a preface to all the complete reporting statements in which the management talks about recent events, discloses essential information regarding expansion and future plans, and discusses significant developments in the business industry.

The business and operating review is a good place for the company to share any good news with the general public. They have room to elaborate on plans that would help enhance the company’s image and address any unpleasant events that may have occurred, to show the customers that they truly care about talking openly to their customers.

Statement of Change in Shareholders’ Equity

The statement of change in shareholders’ equity is also known as equity analysis. It provides information about all the changes in the company’s equity value over a certain time period. It reconciles the opening balances of the equity accounts with the closing balances. There are two types of changes expressed in the statement of change in shareholders’ equity:

  1. Changes arising from any transactions conducted with shareholders of the company. For example, issuing new shares, paying dividends, purchasing treasury stock, and issuing bonus shares, etc.
  2. Changes that are a result of alterations in the comprehensive income of the company. These changes might include revaluation of fixed assets, net income for the period and fair value of for-sale investments, etc.

Notes to the Financial Statements

Notes to the financial statements are basically additional information provided in a company’s financial statements. These notes provide details and information that are left out of the main reporting documents. They are important for the sake of clarity on many points as they outline the accounting methodology used for recording certain transactions. The notes to the financial statements are essentially footnotes because if included in the main statements, they would obscure the important information, as they are generally quite elaborate and detailed.

The following notes are usually used to impart important disclosures for explaining the numbers on the financial statements:

  1. Notes that show the basis for presentation
  2. Notes that advise on significant accounting policies
  3. Notes about valuing inventory
  4. Notes about depreciating assets
  5. Notes about intangible assets
  6. Notes that disclose subsequent events
  7. Notes about employee benefits
  8. Notes that reveal contingency plans

PROBLEMS WITH FINANCIAL STATEMENT ANALYSIS

Financial statement analysis is a brilliant tool to gauge the past performance of a company and predict future performance, but there are several issues that one should be aware of before using the financial statement analysis results blindly, as these issues can interfere with how the results are interpreted. Some of the issues are:

Comparability between Companies

This is a big issue for analysts because they can seemingly compare financial statement analyses between different companies on the basis of ratios used, but in reality it may not paint an accurate picture. The financial ratios of two different companies may be compared to see how they match up against each other, but each company may aggregate all their information different from each other in order to draw up their accounting statements. This may lead to incorrect conclusions drawn about a company in relation to other companies in the industry.

Comparability between Periods

The change in accounts where financial information is stored may skew the results of the financial statement analysis, from one period to the next. For example, if a company records an expense in one period as cost of goods sold, while in another period, it is recorded as a selling and distribution expense, the analysis between those two periods would not be comparable.

Operational Information

Analysts do not take into account operational information of a company, as only financial information is analyzed and reviewed. There may be several indicators in operational information of the company which may be predictors of future performance, for example, the number of backlogged orders, any changes in licenses or warranty claims submitted to the company or even changes in the culture and work environment. Therefore, analysis of financial information may only relay half the story.

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons under public domain, Wikimedia Commons | Microsoft under public domain.

Financial statements are records that can provide indications of the financial health of a company. Accurate financial records are necessary to keep track of financial warning signals such as inordinately high expenses, high levels of debt or a poor record of collecting bills. Public companies often have specific procedures for gathering, verifying and reporting financial information. Recent corporate scandals have placed greater scrutiny on the managers and corporate officers of publicly held firms. Privately held firms are not held to the same standard but often adhere to strict guidelines in order to increase the value of the firm and viability in case of sale.

Keywords Accounting; Accounting Methods; Accounts Payable; Accounts Receivable; Assets; Balance Sheet; Cash Flow; Cash Flow Statement; Current Assets; Current Liabilities; Fixed Costs; Liabilities

Finance: Financial Statement Analysis

Overview

Financial statements are reports that show the financial position of a company. Recordkeeping is important in order to understand a company's value and to comply with various regulations and tax requirements. Accurate records allow companies to account for how money was spent and handled, what assets are owned and what debts are owed.

Businesses differ in how they are valued depending on whether they are public or private firms. Information about public companies is available, especially to shareholders, while it is difficult to get audited and financially sound information about the financial workings of a private company (Antia, 2006). Antia (para. 2) calls the value of a business the "free cash flow" that has various adjusted risk elements deducted from it. Private companies don't provide information on their cash flow and have greater opportunities to engage in financial benefits not available to public companies, such as:

  • Above-market salaries for family members.
  • Mixing of personal and business funds.
  • Exaggeration of business expenses to reduce taxes.

Other concerns regarding a business' value can depend on what a buyer sees in the business. If the business represents a strategic purchase, a higher price might be garnered even for an over-valued private business. If a buyer is a minority buyer, they may want to pay less due to the minimal amount of control they can exert on the business (Antia, para. 3).

Types of Financial Statements

Basic financial statements include the balance sheet, the income statement, cash flow statement and notes to account. There are different types of reports because different types of information are needed to effectively manage a company and plan for the future. Sometimes companies use financial reporting information internally, and in some cases they are required to release this information externally. Tracy (1999) called cash the "lubricant" of business. Without cash it is difficult for a business to function and it increases the likelihood that a business may fail. But, Tracy warned that cash flows only show part of the picture and give no information about the business' profit or financial condition. Since cash flows only show part of the picture, other types of financial reports are needed.

The most common financial reports are the balance sheet and the income statement.

  • The balance sheet (also called the statement of financial position) provides information about the financial condition of a company.
  • The income statement (also called the earnings or profit and loss statement) shows the profitability of the business.

Balance Sheets

The general categories on balance sheets are assets and liabilities. A publicly traded firm also includes shareholder equity. A typical balance sheet shows assets a company owns. Assets include cash, accounts receivable, inventory and any prepaid expenses. Balance sheets also record property the company owns and any depreciation on assets. The balance sheet is a two-sided report because it records assets on one side and liabilities on the other. Liabilities include accounts payable and accrued expenses, income tax owed, loans and stockholders' equity. Stockholders' or shareholders' equity is any claim that owners of company stock have against the assets that a company has. Stockholders' or shareholders' equity is also called net worth. Stockholders' equity is found by deducting liabilities and debt from assets (Morgenson & Harvey, 2002).

Income Statements

Income statements show the profitability of a business. The income statement is for a period of one year and shows the total sales revenue for the year. Subtracted from sales revenue is the cost of goods sold or the expenses a company incurs in producing finished goods to sell. Also deducted from the revenue are expenses for operating costs and depreciation. If a company is publicly owned, its income statement must also report earnings per share (Tracy, 1999). Earnings per share is a measure of company profitability (Godin, 2001). It is calculated by dividing net income by the total shares of stock. When looking at the income statement of a company, the profitability isn't just the gross profit, it is also important to look at the ratio of expenses as a percentage of profit. If a company has high profits but also has high expenses, the company could be mismanaged.

Balance sheets are not only important to companies but also to investors (Godin, p. 52). Balance sheets can tell investors whether or not a company is a good investment based on its financial condition. Financial statements are often prepared by accountants and reviewed by auditors to ensure that the records are accurate and to avoid the temptation not to report factual information or to hide financial flaws. A reason business owners may use financial professionals is to reduce the chance of error and to stay out of an area where they may not have expertise. O'Bannon (2005) cautioned business owners against being lulled to sleep by the power of current accounting software products, which cannot replace the knowledge gained by using professional financial advice. O'Bannon felt that one of the primary benefits of the newer software is that it allows owners and financial advisors to speak the same language and lets business owners provide easy to use documentation to their accountant. Accountants and other financial advisors can use software to quickly perform somewhat complex analysis and generate reports for their clients.

Arar (2012) wrote that small businesses operating in the 2010s have "more accounting software options than ever, including Web-based subscriptions." For those businesses with large inventories or client databases, however, or those that choose not to entrust data to the cloud, such desktop tools as Acclivity AccountEdge Pro 2012, Intuit QuickBooks 2013, and Sage 50 Complete Accounting 2013 are good options (Arar 2012).

Analyzing Balance Sheet

Analyzing balance sheets and income statements requires more than simply reading the categories of figures. The numbers have to be read with an eye towards what they mean and what they might mean in combination. Scott (2005, p. 108) stated that financial statement analysis means interpreting the data "in a meaningful way" instead of looking at "past results." This can mean looking at the company's management strategy, the way the business is operated and the plans the business has for the future. Scott suggested asking the following questions to get close to figuring out how internal factors, especially management, influence financial statement content:

  • How is the company distinguishing itself from the competition?
  • How does it compete? E.g., on price, quality, responsiveness, availability?
  • Is the company's strategy viable given the marketplace economy?
  • Is management adapting its strategy to a changing environment?

These questions and others can provide qualitative information in addition to the quantitative numbers provided in financial statements. Using the information in aggregate can give a broader picture of the company's financial health.

Ratio Analysis

Ratios are one method of analyzing what financial statements may mean. There are several types of ratios including liquidity and profitability ratios. Ratio analysis shows the relationship between financial information, the way it behaves over time and what risks are implied by the behavior (Morgenson & Harvey, 2002).

Liquidity ratios are a measure of how 'liquid' a company is or how well it can come up with cash or quickly converted assets that can help the company meet its financial obligations. If the ratio is high, that is a good number. An example of a liquidity ratio is to divide current assets by current liabilities. The result shows how much cash is available for the company to manage current financial requirements. A quick ratio is a liquidity ratio that eliminates slow moving inventory from current assets to give a more accurate picture of a company's liquidity. Companies can compare their liquidity to others in their industry to see how they fare among similar companies. A debt to equity ratio is a measure of the ability of a company to use debt to finance its operations. Profitability ratios measure the company's profit performance by comparing profits to sales. Companies that last are able to remain profitable even under unfavorable...

0 thoughts on “Annual Report Analysis Research Paper”

    -->

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *